Demystifying 1800s Recipes For the Modern Kitchen > build your 1800s Thanksgiving menu 1800’s Thanksgiving Day MenusPumpkin Pie (1845)Cranberry Sauce (1845)Mince Pies (1887)Family Pie Paste (1873)Apple Pie (1845)Hot Chocolate (1877)Hickory Nut or Walnut Cake (1887)Apple Mince-Meat (1877)Blackberry Cordial (1871)Plum Catsup (1894)Spice Salt (1885) > Latest on the site Pea Soup (1887)Ginger Snaps ( c. Mid 1800s)Maine Manuscript Cook Book (mid-late 1800s)A Weekly Meal Plan (1885)How to Start Yeast (1885)New Year’s Cakes (1871)Huckleberry Cake (1871)Potato Soup (1892)Peach Tapioca Pudding (1876)Peach Butter (1892)Raspberry Cordial (1838)Vanilla Ice Cream (1881) See more recipes → > Looking for a particular topic or recipe? SearchSearch > Popular Categories DrinksBreadsSoupsCakes & Cookies You can also browse the whole recipe file here.